I plan to do an inexpensive sous vide setup using the Sous Vide Magic controller. Currently I don't have a crockpot or rice cooker. Which would work best in a sous vide setup?
By Joey Barry on Monday, November 15 at 07:06 PM
4 Replies So Far
Although either will work find, from the reading I have done, the consensus was the rice cooker is the preferred solution. Since the heating element is located in the bottom a rice cooker can recover temperature drops more quickly. There are two other things to consider in making your choice. Make sure the crockpot or rice cooker you chose can hold the size items you plan to sous vide. Also, be careful that the heating unit you purchase can be turned on and off using the plug. Some of the newer unit with spiffy controls don't turn back on once they've been unplugged.
By RollinLog on Monday, November 15 at 07:34 PM
I'd go rice cooker. I think they both would work about the same in the sous vide application. However, the rice cooker is a lot more flexible for other applications. In addition to making rice you can use the cooker to make stews, soups, pasta, risotto, grits and many other things. There are even cookbooks devoted to rice cookers.
By Mike S on Monday, November 15 at 08:34 PM
There are a number of options, the rice cooker or crock pot being only two of them. In many regards it will come down to what you have access to and in which country you currently reside.
For all intents and purposes the rice cooker gives you by far the more numerous options with regard to control, and volume. As such, if these are the only choices you're looking at entertaining, the go with the largest rice cooker you can afford. The biggest ones, are usually quite dumb with regard to temp control - which is a good thing.
Each device has it' positives and negatives. For sous vide cooking these are the factors that need to be considered. Heat ramp, how quickly does it heat? Thermal stability, how well does it maintain temperature? Heating accuracy and over shooting, does it overheat by a little or a lot? Thermal shock, when you put something cold into it, does the temp remain close to original or does it need (lots) more heating afterwards and who much?
From all the work done before now, the general indication is that the bigger the 'water bath' the more temperature stable it will be. Next, a PID controller with accurate temp probe is very important especially if cooking delicate products like seafood. Circulation of the water is a definite plus as this helps to maintain a more even temperature through out the bath, whereas non-circulating bath, whilst they do have convection effects, can tend to develop heat zones, as such in this case, smaller is better.
Crockpots are usually, not always, heater by a smallish button heater through direct contact with a ceramic pot. The ceramic pot builds up a thermal mass but because of the, usually, cheap heater and thermostat, can have wildly fluctuating temperature ramps - overshooting the target temp. Rice cookers, because they are usually thin mettal pots tends to have larger heating pads to minimize the potential for scorching, this is benefit for sosu bride cooking as it spreads the heating area over a wider portion of the base of the pot. You can also get electric double boilers that heat water with a built inemmersin heater and then transfer heat to double lidded ceramic pots. Such devices are a great item for hacking as a sous vide cooker as they are already built for handling and heating water.
Other options you might consider is using a PID controller, and moble, water proof temp probe, with a switch box and plugin in what ever it is you want to temp control. This open the options up to using anything that can boil water, electrically, e.g. A wide mouth Birko, or electric jug, or something larger like a commercial Bain Marie - bear in mind, that water ovens, like the Sous Vide Supreme, are accurate, digitally controlled non-circulating (Bain maries) water baths. Their size, and the perforated plate in the bottom, helps to enhance production of convection currents within the device. If you want to do something similar in a rice cooker, get a sheet metal worker to build you a false bottom or tribes out of s/s sheet with 2-4mm dia holes in the sheet.
If you have a particularly, large rice cooker and want to explore the options for circulating the water, there are a number of options. It's been mentioned that you could use and immersible fish tank pump, you could also use a self-priming pump, use a non-contact peristaltic pump as longer as you prime it before use, or any other of a number of pump options. Another alternative it to take a coffee milk frogged - yes, a battery operated coil on a stick and try that, get something larger like a hobby craft paint mixer and attach it to a DC motor, source a long shafted impellor, or recycle the plunger from a single serve French Press. There are many, creative options to try.
Of course all of this is moot, if you don't have an adequate method of excluding air from the bag you're sealing your food in. At it's most simle, is cling wrap and a ziploc bag in a sink of water. A double zip ziploc bag is better, and sealing a smaller ziploc bag wrapped by a larger bag that is immersed in water is an excellent method to consider. Of course, if you can get a vacuum packer, all the better.
Ok, so I've rambled on a bit, so in summary, a rice cooker is better than a crockpot both from a size perspective and from a heating perspective. Get yourself a false bottom for the cooker as this will help with thermal circulation. Keep the size of you food in the cooker in proportion, smaller is better than trying to cook in bulk due to the time required to maintain temperature and regain a stable temperature range.
By 'Doc' Tempest on Saturday, January 01 at 06:40 PM
I have a set up with an Auber temp controller $150 and I used a crock pot with a Elite Mini A130 $10 circulator aquarium pump (not an air pump)With great results. I just bought a clear Cambro 5 gal container $18 and a Allied Precision 742G 1000 Watt Bucket Heater $25. This thing can boil 5 gallons of water if let it go so recovery should be a snap with this. The pump has worked like a champ too! Its tiny and can pump 58gph and has suction cups and you can adjust the water flow and it sticks anywhere you need it to go. It fit in my 7qt crock pot with 4 beef tenderloins I didn't want an air pump because it would pump cool air into the water bath and cause the system to work more. If your bath is at 185 and your pumping in 70 deg air.. Well I think you get it! I plan on making some chicken tomorrow with the bucket heater and the cambro container.
By Robert Bafundo on Thursday, January 06 at 05:16 AM
Our free Cooking Sous Vide newsletter will be sent every few weeks and each edition will contain tips, tricks, recipes, and how-to's for Cooking Sous Vide. They will also contain links to some of the best sous vide information on the internet. Subscribe Now!
Disclaimer: Sous vide is a new and largely untested method of cooking. It carries many inherent health risks that may not be fully understood. The information on this site is for informational purposes only. Anyone undertaking sous vide cooking should fully inform themselves about any and all risks associated with it and come to their own conclusions. Following anything on this site may make you sick and should only be done if you are fully aware of the potential complications.
Disclaimer: Some links on this site may be referral links that if used to purchased products from we may receive money. We like money but we will not endorse something we don't believe in, and feel free to go to any products we link to directly and bypass the referral link if you feel uncomfortable with us receiving funds.